Launch A Real Estate Career You Love.
Partner With The #1 Team In the Keller Williams Ohio Valley Region, serving OH and KY
Our mission is to change lives one home at a time with genuine dedication, personalized service, and a commitment to excellence and community service, building lifelong clients along the way.
Community Impact
OVER 90 YEARS OF COMBINED SELLING IN KENTUCKY & OHIO
$317,079,000
Volume Sold
2500+
Families Served
22,000+
Leads Generated
Our Vision
Welcome to The Cindy Shetterly Team, where real estate is about more than just buying and selling. With our team of 13 licensed agents and dedicated administrative experts, we're focused on making a real difference. Beyond transactions, we're all about creating life-changing experiences in Kentucky and Ohio. Our goal? Building lasting relationships with our clients that go beyond just one sale. Join us as we shape the future of real estate with our commitment to excellence and meaningful connections.
Our Values
Real estate is more than a job; it's a pathway to financial freedom, community, gratitude, and productivity. Not only are we a team, but a family, united by our shared values of integrity, dedication, and unwavering support for one another. At The Cindy Shetterly Team, we embrace the uniqueness of each individual, recognizing that it's our differences that make us stronger together.
A Proven Team Model
IF YOU WANT TO GO FAR, GO TOGETHER
Community focused
Results-Oriented
Competent
Enthusiastic
Connected
Aligned
AGENTS ON OUR TEAM SELL ON AVERAGE...
415 / year
Homes
$115M+
In Volume
Apply To Join Our Team Of Experts
Welcome to The Cindy Shetterly Team where we offer an inviting pathway to a fulfilling career in real estate. Whether you're a seasoned professional seeking a fresh challenge or a newcomer with a passion for the industry, our team provides a supportive community and a wealth of opportunities in sales, operations, and marketing. With our commitment to nurturing individual growth, we empower every member to thrive. Join us on this exciting journey of personal and professional development, where each day brings new chances for success and celebration. Together, let's build a career you love at The Cindy Shetterly Team.
Meet Our Founder
FOUNDER & CEO
Cindy Shetterly
Cindy has never looked back after flying for Delta Airlines for 17 years and moved full force into RE. When she is not busy listing homes and doing real estate related things, she loves volunteering with local charities, traveling with her husband Andy and visiting her daughter who has transplanted to Arizona.
Meet Our Listing Team
Meet Our Operations Team
Venus Bertucci
listing manager
Venus Started her real estate in 2015. Little did she know that this "part time" job to keep her busy as her three kids were all in school would turn into a thriving business. Venus has the entire package that sellers need in getting their homes listed on the market. From ideas, strategies and compassion in this difficult time, she has them covered. Venus is enthusiastic and a true professional. This has led her career on the Cindy Shetterly team as the Lead Listing Expert.
Victoria Wood
listing specialist
Victoria has been a part of The Cindy Shetterly Team on both sides. In 2007, Victoria met Cindy on the selling and buying side of their own homes. She always has thought of real estate as the perfect career as her kids aged and became more self-sufficient. Victoria started with The Cindy Shetterly Team in 2020 and quickly became a fantastic buyers agent. Victoria
has now established her role as a Listing assistant to help our sellers achieve a five star service. Her incredible customer service has been a true asset for the team.
Marcie Rottinghaus
Director of operations
As a seasoned real estate professional with over 15 years of experience, Marcie navigates the intricate landscape of real estate sales and operations. Her journey began with hands-on roles, learning the ropes of the industry from the ground up. Over the years, she has seamlessly transitioned into leadership positions, directing operations for The Cindy Shetterly Team and driving bottom-line results. Outside of work, she loves to travel to visit her three boys and extended family that are spread across the country, continually focusing on health, wellness and spending quality time with her furry companions
Amanda Brady
transaction coordinator
Amanda was originally licensed in North Carolina in 2018, where the drive to help her family and friends with their real estate needs led her back to home to Kentucky in 2019. Working with the Cindy Shetterly team as their client care coordinator has opened up even more opportunities to help each one of our buyers and sellers during these incredible transactions and monumental moves in their lives. As well as being a full time dog mom of two, she is also anxiously awaiting September when she will become an aunt to her soon to be nephew Brady!
Meet Our Buyers Agents
Christy Cade
Buyer agent
As a licensed realtor in KY and OH, Christy has spent over a decade watching the dream of homeownership happen. Growing up in the area has given her insight to help homebuyers find the perfect location for them all while giving her the opportunity to continue to see our area grow. Working with Veterans is her specialty but she can help anyone achieve their dream of owning a home. From putting you in touch with a local lender, to shopping for a home, to inspections and the closing table, Christy will do her best to make your experience as easy as possible.
Ashley Cheek
buyer agent
The last 7 years in real estate have been challenging as well as very rewarding for Ashley. She has exceeded all of her expectations of what she could accomplish and has created a comfortable lifestyle for her family by doing something that she's passionate about. Raising two kids with her husband Matt is her true passion as well as serving God and the community. Ashley takes incredible pride in finding the perfect home for each and everyone of her clients and her incredible calmness and meticulous negotiating skills make her a leader in the industry.
Kristy Goetz
buyer agent
Representing Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky homeowners and future homeowners, Kristy is committed to listening to her clients needs, guiding them through the buying process, and utilizing her negotiating skills to ensure a successful transaction. After earning her Bachelors and Masters, she joined the Real Estate profession.
In the past six years, Kristy has become an esteemed realtor, highly recommended by her clients. While Kristy is busy making lifelong relationships and home purchasing dreams come true, she is also busy with her three children Nolan, Ayla, and Carter. Her family is everything!
Jennifer Smallwood
buyer agent
Jennifer has a keen knowledge for understanding the importance of customer service from the restaurant industry. As a family owned business for over 35 years in the renowned De Felice in Covington, Jen has done everything from manufacturing their famous sauce, to cooking and serving clients day in and day out. The integral parts of running a restaurant seamlessly worked in creating the perfect recipe for working with buyers in the real estate business. Starting with the Cindy Shetterly team has brought me opportunities that have been life changing and I have only one regret that I didn't start earlier in real estate.
Shawn Thomas
Buyer agent
After 25 successful years in the restaurant business, Shawn made the exciting transition into real estate, and it's been the best decision he's ever made. For the past seven years, he's had the privilege of helping people find their dream homes while building friendships that last a lifetime. It's more than a career for him; it's his passion. He prioritizes God, family, and work, in that order. When you find your big 'Why,' you love to get up every day and go to work, and he has found his in helping others achieve their real estate dreams.
Todd Asalon
buyer agent
After coaching college baseball for over 28 years, Todd made the switch to Keller Williams and real estate and couldn’t be happier. He was privileged to coach at Northern Kentucky University and Thomas More University and serve the student athletes there. He was born and raised in Cincinnati, but now resides in Villa Hills, Kentucky. He is licensed in both Ohio and Kentucky and looks forward to serving both sides of the river.
Taylor Hays
buyer agent
As a native to the Cincinnati suburbs, Taylor has knowledge of the city and surrounding areas, and a lifetime of first-hand experience. She relocated to the Northern Kentucky area about 10 years ago and has made this Big Blue state home for herself and her family. As a mom of 3, you can always find her on the go or helping someone in some way! She loves to be active, adventuring outdoors, making art, and having movie nights. Her goal is to be as impactful as she can be everyday, and she works hard to pour that into both her family and her business!.
Meet Our Inside Sales & Marketing Team
Jaime Navarro
ISA
Jaime is an experienced Inside Sales Agent, specializing in connecting leads with our team through exceptional customer service and market expertise. In this role, Jaime diligently follows up on leads, provides valuable property information, and coordinates appointments to ensure a seamless home buying or selling experience. With a strong background in sales and a passion for real estate, Jaime is committed to exceeding client expectations and building lasting relationships. Dedicated to leveraging the latest technology and local market insights, Jaime helps the team achieve remarkable results.
Kobey Price
Marketing
Kobey graduated from the Ignite Institute and is a marketing intern with The Cindy Shetterly Team. He's been helping out with marketing strategies and contact management, bringing fresh ideas to the table. Kobey's creativity has really helped boost the team's visibility. He will be attending the University of Cincinnati.
Izzy Harris
Social media & Design
Ever since Izzy was a little girl, real estate has piqued her interest. Some 10 years later, and that interest has only grown. She supports the team in crafting compelling campaigns, engaging with our audience, and connecting our community of clients. In her free time, she loves taking her dogs on scenic drives, hiking in national parks, and discovering new, fun places for day trips. She's passionate about combining her love for exploration with innovative marketing strategies in the real estate industry.
Testimonials
Cindy says "This past 20 years has flown by and gives me great joy knowing I have helped 1000's of families change their lives with homeownership."
Venus says "I had no idea I could be so passionate about real estate. I love my kids and family so much and this opportunity has allowed us freedom in wonderful vacations and savings that have surpassed any expectations I have ever had."
Victoria says "I love being on the buy and sell side of a transaction and this opportunity arose so I jumped in immediately."
Amanda says "I am so blessed to be able to help so many families throughout my years with the team and I love being able to simplify and make the process as seamless as possible for everyone involved."
Ashley says "I can't imagine my life and how different it would be without real estate. Being part of a team has been not only a support system but an amazing growth platform in my business."
Jen says "My whole life the importance of relationship building was instilled in us as a family".
Office:
7210 Turfway Rd, Florence KY 41042
Phone:
(859) 743-0212
Email:
Website:
https://thecindyshetterlyteam.com
Copyright © 2024, all right reserved. Privacy Policy.